Jump to content

Why do you not draw in 1:1


Recommended Posts

Hi. I am a garden designer who has previously used AutoCAD for technical drawing output and Sketchup for 3D presentations.  I am hoping to use Vectorworks landmark for both and I thought that was the whole point of the software.  Why is it then that you have to assign a scale to draw in workspace and not when you output.  I may wish to have a plan in 1:50 and some details in 1:20 and also use the same drawing for a 3D visual.  How can I possibly know what to draw in before I start?  Do I have to re draw the whole thing for each drawing?!  Im sure this can not be the case.

  • Like 2
Link to comment

You absolutely do not have to do any redrawing.

 

Design Layer scale will give you a simulation of what the output will look like at an intended scale on your screen. If you zoom the view to 100% then the objects will be exactly the same size as they will be on the printed page at the scale of your design layer. It will give you a good idea of what your line weights, dash styles etc etc will look like when they are finally printed at the predominant scale that you intend to use. 

 

You can change the design Layer scale at any time though.

 

When outputting to viewports you should pick the scale that you have been using in the design layers, but you certainly don't have to. If you want to rescale lineweights and other resources because your viewports are at a different scale for say, details etc, then you can rescale most resources from the advanced properties section of the viewports.

 

This is IMO a much more user friendly workflow than the AutoCAD one which I used to find very unpredictable. However, that was quite a long time ago, and I am sure things must have moved on in AutoCAD since then....

 

 

  • Like 2
Link to comment

AFAIK vw's 'ability' to draw in modelspace at scales other than 1:1 predates viewports. I have never drawn anything at other than 1:1 in either acad, sketchup or vw.

 

IDK why VW continues to have this 'feature' as sometimes it results in messes where you import a file and get some odd scaling, also something to watch out for when waking up very old jobs.

Link to comment

@Paul Johnson You might want to watch a few training videos to get you started on the right foot as the program can be a little confusing coming from AutoCAD, though the workflows are not radically different once you get a handle on organizing your drawings with Classes (autocad layers), Design Layers (autoCAD model space), and Sheet Layers (autocad paperspace).

 

I say this as someone who used AutoCAD for 20 years before switching to Vectorworks.  Invest some time in  https://learn.archoncad.com and it will get easy in weeks rather than months.

Link to comment
On 2/13/2021 at 8:19 PM, Paul Johnson said:

Hi. I am a garden designer who has previously used AutoCAD for technical drawing output and Sketchup for 3D presentations.  I am hoping to use Vectorworks landmark for both and I thought that was the whole point of the software.  Why is it then that you have to assign a scale to draw in workspace and not when you output.  I may wish to have a plan in 1:50 and some details in 1:20 and also use the same drawing for a 3D visual.  How can I possibly know what to draw in before I start?  Do I have to re draw the whole thing for each drawing?!  Im sure this can not be the case.


Garden designer using Autocad? 

OMG welcome to the new life!

 

 

Link to comment

This has been discussed previously and it's one of those things about VW that is more confusing than it needs to be. When you are asked what scale you'd like your layer to be at, it suggests that you're setting something intrinsic to the layer but you're not. You're just setting how you'd like to "view" that layer whilst working in it.

 

It would be much more logical (and useful) to have this as something you choose on the fly, along with things like render mode and projection.

 

I realise there might be legacy reasons to leave it where it is... but it could at least be renamed to something like "scaled viewing simulation" (OK, something better than that, but less confusing than how it's currently presented).

  • Like 2
Link to comment

Scale functionality sets the multiplication factor for the printable area in a Design Layer(s) in addition to annotation placed in those environments. No more manually sizing up or down text fonts (such as when used in AC's Model Space) to suit the final print output.

The plus of VWs is that a work file can contain more than one Design Layer with different scales and visibility whereas the last time I worked with AutoCad only one Model Space existed per file, excluding Xref functionality. A 3d model can be created at the centre of it's own environment without other 3d objects potentially being visible to one side or the other. Very flexible!

Link to comment
  • 2 weeks later...
On 2/16/2021 at 9:37 PM, LarryO said:

...The plus of VWs is that a work file can contain more than one Design Layer with different scales and visibility ...

This is a really useful function that was never played up in the tutorials I watched when getting my head around VW after years (and years) of AutoCAD.

I use it often now, but I still think it's confusing to have it as a byproduct of 'Scale' instead of it's own feature. I arbitrarily choose a scale slightly bigger or smaller for no real reason except that I can 'isolate those drawings.

 

I absolutely agree with @line-weight about a more logical naming ("scaled viewing simulation" isn't it! ).

But something to describe that you are not drawing in 1/4=1'-0" but 1:1 AND that the workspace is simulating scaled annotations and line weights for a InDesign like 'preflight.'

 

Maybe call it 'scale preflight'... 

  • Like 1
Link to comment

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...